The Dark Knight

Christopher Nolan’s The Dark Knight is a challenging picture that still provokes one’s definitions of heroism and vigilantism more than a decade later. It depicts torture as a somewhat effective means of intelligence gathering. It depicts extraordinary rendition as helpful. It demonstrates secretive mass surveillance of citizen’s cell phones to be extremely effective and necessary under the right circumstances. It’s a film that presents the obstruction of justice for the murder of 5 cops as justifiable for social cohesion and a cleaner narrative. And it depicts a city government telling this lie to its citizens.

In case it wasn’t obvious then, or now, The Dark Knight is a parable for the United States’ vigilante role of sheriff of the liberal world order, with special emphasis on the Iraq War era. Nolan’s achievement is realizing the potential of a philosophical battle between Batman and Joker to server as an imperfect mirror to current events and a politically plural audience.

A few observations that stuck with me on this recent viewing:

  • The expansive mob network that effectively runs Gotham City is operating as a money laundering outfit for dark money emanating from mainland China via Mr. Lau’s company. The implication is that dirty money from China is directly empowering the rot in Gotham.
  • The reason Mr. Lau runs to Hong Kong is because China will not extradite one of its citizens to a foreign power under nearly any circumstances. That Nolan is including irregular international extradition law as a key plot challenge for Batman went way over my head when I first saw this.
    • A digression: This is the second Nolan Batman film where China and Chinese culture plays an elliptical role in the proceedings. In Batman Begins, Bruce Wayne is seen speaking Chinese after committing a robbery abroad, eventually finding himself in a prison in Bhutan. And notably, the terrorist organization Bruce briefly joins called the League of Shadows, headed by Ra’s al Ghul, is depicted as a vaguely Indo-Chinese faction by their fighting style, garb, set design and from the casting of the other members.
  • The final action sequence takes place in an under-construction building from which Joker is conducting his ferry-prisoners-dilemma spectacle and holding hospital patients hostage in clown mask disguises. That building was then under-construction Trump International Hotel and Tower in Chicago. . .

Erotics in The Rise of Skywalker trailer

Since the Star Wars Episode IX trailer dropped last Friday, I have enjoyed the vast mixture of excitement, concern, apathy and cultural bemusement the internet generated in response. I share the general complaint that people who care about Star Wars have noted so far, that it appears director JJ Abrams intends to undo much of what Rian Johnson built up in The Last Jedi. Johnson introduced a vision of the Force that was more egalitarian and not something that belonged exclusively to the elite Skywalker bloodline. He also reconnected the series’ imagery and themes with the original roots of the Star Wars franchise, directly referencing Kurosawa films and Joseph Campbell. I anticipate that this new movie could be disappointing, both as a Star Wars fan and as a movie snob, but on the latter front perhaps there is a new hope.

Upon re-watching the trailer again this morning I was struck by the first sequence that features a desert stand-off between Rey and a TIE fighter whose unseen pilot is almost certainly her nemesis and possible future boyfriend, Kylo Ren. What I noticed made me want to add to this conversation in a constructive way.

The most exciting aspect of The Last Jedi was Johnson’s erotic approach to the Force and the developing relationship between Rey and Kylo. Their mind-melds and physical encounters were characterized by symmetry, reciprocity, anticipation, submission, teamwork, compassion and great tension. Their images together featured phallic symbols, leather, moisture and sweat, touching, heavy exertion, and even nudity. The lightsaber as a shared tool of immense power goes without saying. . . they even have a pseudo-sex scene after the death of Snoke where they team up to shred a gang of red-plastic and leather plated BDSM bodyguards with kinky red knife-whips! If this trailer is any indication, it seems that Abrams noticed this aspect in The Last Jedi and actually intends to build upon the erotics of Episode VIII. To illustrate this possibility, I am going to describe the 13 shots that comprise this sequence in the trailer. Note, I am not going to include the Luke Skywalker voiceover featured in the trailer, as this is distracting and unlikely to be featured anywhere in the final film. Here goes:

Shot 1 – (14 Seconds) First we hear Rey’s heavy breathing before we open on a medium shot of Rey in a desert. It is likely that we are either on the planet Jakku (her childhood home world where her parents orphaned her) or Tatooine (her mentor Luke Skywalker’s childhood home world). She is visibly distressed and glistening in the heat, but begins to control her breathing as we zoom in to center on her face and then pan down to her tool belt as she un-holsters her lightsaber with her right hand and pulls it across her body, left to right. Rey is wearing what can only be described as a beige Jedi monk outfit.

Shot 2 – (4 seconds) Cut to behind Rey’s back for a master shot of the desert. Due to perspective, she is about as tall as any of the nearby mountains and is standing centered on the left third of the frame. The camera is at hip elevation and so the sky is the dominate element of the frame. A cloud is blocking this planets sun for the moment. A closer scan reveals a black ship, barely a dot on an iPhone screen, approaching in the right third of the frame, mirrored across the vertical axis from Rey’s lightsaber. This left-right pairing will be reinforced throughout this sequence.

Shot 3 – (4 seconds) A close-up from behind Rey’s right hip, lightsaber in hand pointed down at an angle. Rey takes up the left third of the frame now. The camera then rack focuses to the black ship in the distance, now brightly reflecting sunlight, which is approaching in the right third of the frame. We hear the looming siren of a TIE fighter’s iconic ion engine as the focus adjusts. Both the tip of Rey’s lightsaber and the approaching ship are again mirrored across the vertical axis of the frame, reinforcing the spatial relationship established in Shot 2. This familiar image evokes many a western stand-off and harkens way back to Star Wars’ western genre heritage. George Lucas originally envisioned the Jedi as space samurai, influenced by the Japanese samurai films of the 1960’s and ‘70’s. But, this is an instance of cultural cross-pollination, as Lucas was surely aware, because the cinematic grammar and warrior code ethos of Japanese samurai films were in part inspired by popular Golden Age Hollywood westerns. Though she isn’t using it, Rey has a blaster holstered on her right hip which further echoes the western theme.

Shot 4 – (3 seconds) A return to the set up at the end of Shot 1, though with Rey a bit to the left. The camera continues to inch forward and we can see she has composed herself and now looks focused on the confrontation in front of her.

Shot 5 – (14 seconds) After a title card, we get a fast-moving drone shot of the desert from a high elevation looking down. The drone quickly pans down and to the left, increasing with speed as the string section of the orchestra hums ominously. This is punctuated by a torrent of dust as a red & black TIE fighter screeches across the screen from right to left. Again, we have Rey on the left, out of frame, and Kylo approaching from the right. This shot, which at first seems to be of nothing is quietly radical! Like a brush stroke, or a lightsaber swipe, the drone camera is physically tracing the trajectory of the approaching showdown.

Shot 6 – (1 second) Same set up as Shot 3 as Rey activates her Blue lightsaber.

Shot 7 – (3 seconds) Camera is at hip level again for medium shot from a few feet behind Rey. Rey is again placed center left as she turns and kneels in a “runners’ mark” position. She is looking straight ahead past the camera as the ship is approaching in the background on the center right.

Shot 8 – (2 seconds) The most erotically charged shot, and the only glimpse of Kylo in this sequence. We see Kylo’s leather gloved hands tighten his steering wheel grip as he thrusts his handles forward, increasing velocity. The interior of the ship is black, grey, and cold in direct contrast to the warm colored sand and heat outside. Red monitors glow in the background adding the only color to the shot.

Shot 9 – (2 seconds) The camera is placed behind Rey’s back again which has us looking in the same direction as Kylo’s approach vector. She turns her head slowly around her left shoulder to glimpse the approaching ship one last time as the camera moves rapidly in for a close-up. The ion engine is now part of the orchestra.

Shot 10 – (1 second) Shot of Rey’s two feet in the sand this time on the right side of the frame as she begins to run from right to left away from Kylo.

Shot 11 – (4 seconds) Rey is running from right to left at full speed as Kylo flies in from the right. The camera is still at hip elevation and is tracking left but at an isometric angle that keeps both characters mirrored across the center-line of the frame, even as the distance between them closes. This is the first shot that has utilized an overtly non-planar angle (with the exception of a slight rotation featured in the drone shot). This shot also uses a wide-angle lens and you can notice the concave curve of the desert ground at the edges of the screen. This has the effect of reinforcing the looming collusion and increasing the gravitational pull of the center.

Shot 12 – (2 seconds) The camera is now placed in front of Rey sprinting at us. Rey is visually engulfed by the spiderweb window of the TIE Fighter cockpit and its four, pointed talons. Her head and the center window are now straddling the frame’s center point. Rey looks to be exerting tremendous effort just before she begins a jump.

Shot 13 – (3 seconds) A slow motion shot of Rey acrobatically twisting through the air as she attempts to vault over Kylo’s TIE Fighter. This final shot is at a more pronounced isometric wide-angle that combines the multiple planes of movement that were illustrated in the previous 12 shots. We fade to black just as Rey’s contortions and Kylo’s cockpit converge in the center of the frame.

The rest of the trailer looks more like standard Abrams. As a director, his greatest strengths are conception, laying the seeds for a series or franchise to grow, and well-paced kinetic action. You can feel the wind in some of the later trailer shots, as haphazard and unmemorable as they are out of context. But with Rey and Kylo, Abrams may be purposely adapting his style to signal a different, more nuanced and erotic grammar for the characters involved. In any action sequence, or movie franchise dependent on lightsaber battles, maintaining and developing consistent spatial relationships like those detailed above are often the only cues the audience gets for how to think about the characters on-screen. Here’s to hoping that that bores out in the final film.

Bordwell in the Times

Bordwell – Hollywood Movies 1919 (NYT)

Film scholar David Bordwell on the American film industry in 1919 and 2019. The internet, and the possibility of streaming, as the equivalent shock effect of the First World War. In terms of stars, I sense that salaries are larger now for a larger group of people than ever before. . . If history is repeating itself and the streamers successfully displace the studios, should we expect star power (in bargaining terms) to lower over time followed by anti-trust realignment of these streaming firms?

Cold War and 2018 Catch-up

Cold War – A fascinating memory project and dissection of how buried histories and superimposed ideologies impact our lives and choices. With this and 2013’s Ida, director Pawel Pawlikowski seems to be embarking on a larger national identity project: What does it mean to be Polish in Europe today? And what did it mean before? He frames his questions here through an epic love story of two musically gifted Poles, as they scurry around mid-century Europe, trying to make sense of what they want from their lives and eachother. Pawlikowski’s direction around framing, time, and sound is worthy of closer examination. My only complaint is that at times the austere manner stifled my emotional connection to the drama. Nevertheless, this is one of the best movies of the year.

Madeline’s Madeline – This movie very cleverly flattens the barriers between mental illness, being a teenager coming of age and rebelling, being a half black girl in liberal NYC, performance, and authority. I really dug how Decker puts each of these factors on the same continuum as borne out by the films style, in particular by the camerawork and editing. Break out performance by Helena Howard as Madeline.

Eighth Grade – Millennial nostalgia and teenagers with social media technology commentary. Burnham as director is surprisingly interested in lighting! The scenes at night with Kayla in the dark of her room, her iPhone as the sole light source, always disrupted momentarily by the light from the hallway door as her father peaks in to say goodnight, are among the film’s best. A little too sappy at the end for my taste, but an excellent comedy overall. Looking forward to more from Bo Burnham and Elsie Fisher.

Private Life – Insightful, and very funny, exploration of a topic that was oblivious to me. Peak Giamatti.

Can You Ever Forgive Me? – A delightfully drab film and a stealth portrait of the AIDS crisis in NYC. The excellent chemistry between Melissa McCarthy and Richard E. Grant makes this an entertaining, if slight, film.

Shirkers – I really applaud the courage a movie like this takes. Jumping back into a painful, life-altering episode and fashioning it for public consumption cannot be fun and Tan graciously chooses to make the experience fun and often exciting. In its construction, it is unlike any film (documentary, or otherwise) that I’ve seen and I won’t spoil exactly why; but in substance I didn’t feel like this was offering much to chew on. George is a fantastic character, the dynamo for the entire project, but as a mysterious, compulsive story-teller/liar I didn’t find much insight that isn’t already covered in better documentaries like Tabloid or The Imposter.

Hold the Dark – People are like wolves! I wanted to like this much more than I did. Wright is convincing as a grizzly wolf expert and Skarsgard is convincing as a tall guy and quite great in the morgue scene. The movie’s momentum and tone just gets shot off the rails after the mid movie gun battle. I also felt that Saulnier failed to get the environment working for him. If there was a buried narrative about Alaska, I was unable to piece it together.

North Macedonia

North Macedonia (NYT)

Belated reactions to this under discussed story. This is very exciting going forward! In my opinion the West should be integrating these Balkan states ASAP. And remarkably, this happened in a time of European disunity and weak American leadership. What is not mentioned in this story: China as a large financier for Greece post-euro crisis has partially freed Greece from Russian influence which sets the larger stage for moves like this. Russia will continue to lose influence as long as energy and antagonism are their main exports.